simple allPairBasketManager

Post by **milanese** » Wed Jul 22, 2015 5:52 pm

Roderick » Wed Jul 22, 2015 5:10 pm wrote:I was logged in when I tried to download the file.

strange it seems for all others to work, or had anyone else problems with the download?

Cheers

Tommaso

Post by **woodlands** » Wed Jul 22, 2015 6:38 pm

Download to any new setup and....
No problems here, using on a daily basis with PPoS and PPoS2 + some of JLG's older EAs, all are functioning perfectly. (PP0S 4% 'close all' again today)

Thanks to Milanese for this manager.
Regards,
Tony

Post by **AltosT** » Wed Jul 22, 2015 6:57 pm

milanese » Thu Jul 23, 2015 3:52 am wrote: strange it seems for all others to work, or had anyone else problems with the download?

Cheers

Tommaso

Yep, no problem downloading here. Does user realize he can be on the board and read all messages without being logged in ? Check at top of page to see that your user name is showing.

madopter1 · Post by **madopter1** » Mon Sep 07, 2015 11:35 am

milanese,

For some reason, I'm having this problem with v1.22

Suppose starting account size is $10000, and AllOverProfit = $100.

If:

Trade #1 is -$200 (due to SL hit on personal EA)
Trade #2 is +$100 (due to TP hit on personal EA)
when Trade #3 becomes (floating) profit $200 then basket should close.

However, v1.22 does not seem to take into account the SL hits (or TP hits) of personal EA in order to calculate a (net) profit target.

In other words, I am looking for a NET profit.

Is it possible to code SAPBTM so that it allows trade until there is a net profit of $100 before closing the basket?

Thank you

Post by **milanese** » Mon Sep 07, 2015 1:39 pm

madopter1 » Mon Sep 07, 2015 11:35 am wrote:milanese,

For some reason, I'm having this problem with v1.22

Suppose starting account size is $10000, and AllOverProfit = $100.

If:

Trade #1 is -$200 (due to SL hit on personal EA)
Trade #2 is +$100 (due to TP hit on personal EA)
when Trade #3 becomes (floating) profit $200 then basket should close.

However, v1.22 does not seem to take into account the SL hits (or TP hits) of personal EA in order to calculate a (net) profit target.

In other words, I am looking for a NET profit.

Is it possible to code SAPBTM so that it allows trade until there is a net profit of $100 before closing the basket?

Thank you

This is so not previsted, as it makes not much sense imo to combinate a basketmanaging EA with individual SL and TP on orders, as it manages the entire basket..

Cheers

Tommaso

madopter1 · Post by **madopter1** » Mon Sep 07, 2015 4:22 pm

milanese » Mon Sep 07, 2015 1:39 pm wrote:
madopter1 » Mon Sep 07, 2015 11:35 am wrote:milanese,

For some reason, I'm having this problem with v1.22

Suppose starting account size is $10000, and AllOverProfit = $100.

If:

Trade #1 is -$200 (due to SL hit on personal EA)
Trade #2 is +$100 (due to TP hit on personal EA)
when Trade #3 becomes (floating) profit $200 then basket should close.

However, v1.22 does not seem to take into account the SL hits (or TP hits) of personal EA in order to calculate a (net) profit target.

In other words, I am looking for a NET profit.

Is it possible to code SAPBTM so that it allows trade until there is a net profit of $100 before closing the basket?

Thank you
This is so not previsted, as it makes not much sense imo to combinate a basketmanaging EA with individual SL and TP on orders, as it manages the entire basket..

Cheers

Tommaso

Hi milanese, I apologize for not making explanation more clear.

I'm not looking to associate your EA with the custom EA's TP or SL.

Please allow me to explain better now:

The only thing I am asking is whether it is possible for SAPBTM to reach the original configured profit target if (from the moment SAPBTM is applied to a chart), if there are losses on the Empty4 terminal (via some SL hits), or, if there gains on the Empty4 terminal (via some TP hits or, manual closing of some orders), that SAPBTM will account for those losses (or gains), and still give you the net profit that you specified originally when you applied SAPBTM to the chart.

I hope I'm more understandable

Post by **milanese** » Mon Sep 07, 2015 4:25 pm

madopter1 » Mon Sep 07, 2015 4:22 pm wrote:
Hi milanese, I apologize for not making explanation more clear.

I'm not looking to associate your EA with the custom EA's TP or SL.

Please allow me to explain better now:

The only thing I am asking is whether it is possible for SAPBTM to reach the original configured profit target if (from the moment SAPBTM is applied to a chart), if there are losses on the Empty4 terminal (via some SL hits), or, if there gains on the Empty4 terminal (via some TP hits or, manual closing of some orders), that SAPBTM will account for those losses (or gains), and still give you the net profit that you specified originally when you applied SAPBTM to the chart.

I hope I'm more understandable

You should, if you use a basketmanager not close single trades, so individual SL or TP for the trades will with basket-management not make much sense, as this EA is thought to manage entire baskets with basket TP and SL, so it will always only consider the entire basket of OPEN positions..
For individual trade management you should better use the APTM.

Cheers

Tommaso

madopter1 · Post by **madopter1** » Mon Sep 07, 2015 4:54 pm

milanese » Mon Sep 07, 2015 4:25 pm wrote:
madopter1 » Mon Sep 07, 2015 4:22 pm wrote:
Hi milanese, I apologize for not making explanation more clear.

I'm not looking to associate your EA with the custom EA's TP or SL.

Please allow me to explain better now:

The only thing I am asking is whether it is possible for SAPBTM to reach the original configured profit target if (from the moment SAPBTM is applied to a chart), if there are losses on the Empty4 terminal (via some SL hits), or, if there gains on the Empty4 terminal (via some TP hits or, manual closing of some orders), that SAPBTM will account for those losses (or gains), and still give you the net profit that you specified originally when you applied SAPBTM to the chart.

I hope I'm more understandable
You should, if you use a basketmanager not close single trades, so individual SL or TP for the trades will with basket-management not make much sense, as this EA is thought to manage entire baskets with basket TP and SL, so it will always only consider the entire basket of OPEN positions..
For individual trade management you should better use the APTM.

Cheers

Tommaso

I will try APTM, thanks. Can you tell me if APTM is capable of accounting for the losses or gains of some of the orders from the basket? (from the time APTM is applied to the chart)

Post by **milanese** » Mon Sep 07, 2015 5:02 pm

madopter1 » Mon Sep 07, 2015 4:54 pm wrote:
I will try APTM, thanks. Can you tell me if APTM is capable of accounting for the losses or gains of some of the orders from the basket? (from the time APTM is applied to the chart)

No this is too for APTM not previsted, but it had very elevated possibilities for individula trade managemnd and too some basket-options, that sAPBTM not has, read careful the topic, as APTM has a lot of functions..

Cheers

Tommaso

madopter1 · Post by **madopter1** » Mon Sep 07, 2015 5:12 pm

milanese » Mon Sep 07, 2015 5:02 pm wrote:
madopter1 » Mon Sep 07, 2015 4:54 pm wrote:
I will try APTM, thanks. Can you tell me if APTM is capable of accounting for the losses or gains of some of the orders from the basket? (from the time APTM is applied to the chart)
No this is too for APTM not previsted, but it had very elevated possibilities for individula trade managemnd and too some basket-options, that sAPBTM not has, read careful the topic, as APTM has a lot of functions..

Cheers

Tommaso

I see. Is it technically possible to do such a thing with MQL4 or MQL5? I'm now wondering whether this is even possible to program.