afeudale » Thu Sep 08, 2016 2:16 pm wrote:Quite new to this forum (only a few posts) and trading (only 3 months)...but grateful to all of those that contribute, especially nanningbob for this indicator!

Few questions/comments:

1) I noticed that the TF indicator on the SuperCSS does not change if you set it for AutoTF and then change TF's. It always shows D1. Unless I'm missing something? I'm using the Gary.Baluda v1.4.

not used in this system ignore it. Only works when doing multiple currency comparisons. Since not comparing with other currency pairs the numbers are the same.

2) Is the output of the above indicator comparable to that of the CurrencySlopeStrength indicator? They seem to show different outputs (even on the same TF) although the patterns seem to be comparable.

formulas are different so not the same. One compares all seven major currencies against all seven currency pair combinations while the other only compares the two on the screen.

3) The Gary.Baluda.CSS has "weighonlysymbolonchart" set to true by default. Should it not be false so that it gives an accurate depiction of the currencies movement against the basket of currencies? If it's set to true, then two lines will essentially just be mirror reflections of each other (or maybe that's the point?)

it means what it says true uses only currencies on the chart. False uses all the currencies.

Trying to recover from a $5k loss in my first month of trading - when I knew nothing at all and thought I was going to "outsmart" the market after Brexit (buying GBP). Ha! I've learned so much since then!

Thanks in advance!

afeudale » Fri Sep 09, 2016 9:50 am wrote:Thanks Bob for the fast reply and info!

Ok, got it, so AutoTF should be "true" for this method and the display will show "D1" regardless - but it's to be ignored.

Still a bit confused on the "weighonlysymbolonchart". The indicator has it set to "true" by default, but in another post by Baluda:

"Setting 'weighOnlySymbolOnChart' to true significantly changes how the indicator works. Using this to lower resource use is not a good idea."

From my understanding, CSS is based on TMA_slope values, so if the above is set to "true" it will give similar information to a TMA_slope indicator.

However, setting it to "false" would give additional information because it is now comparing the two currencies to the entire basket of currencies.

For example, on EURUSD, setting to "true" compares strength of EUR to USD only. Setting to "false" compares EUR to all other currencies and USD also to all other currencies. More info, thus more sound trading decisions.

Unless I'm completely missing something here

yamez » Sun Sep 11, 2016 3:52 am wrote:AUDNZD H1. Nice friday night/Saturday morning trade.

nanningbob » Wed Sep 07, 2016 3:47 am wrote:We are cleaning up the code now. The signals will only be for the first currency of the pair. So it will say gbp/chf cross up or down. gbp/chf cross up 2.0 or cross down 2.0 or cross down -2.0 or cross up -2.0. Hopefully this will cause fewer signals and which direction that currency pair is going.

Haggadah » Sun Sep 11, 2016 12:14 pm wrote:

nanningbob » Wed Sep 07, 2016 3:47 am wrote:We are cleaning up the code now. The signals will only be for the first currency of the pair. So it will say gbp/chf cross up or down. gbp/chf cross up 2.0 or cross down 2.0 or cross down -2.0 or cross up -2.0. Hopefully this will cause fewer signals and which direction that currency pair is going.

NB,

One question on the attached PIC when the field WeightOnlySymbolOnChart is set to true. The weight of the two pairs is inversely (positively correlated and negatively correlated) equal. It should not be the case.

Thanks,'

Haggadah