stevehopwoodforex.com
https://www.stevehopwoodforex.com/phpBB3/
Print view

Ditto - Empty4 to Oanda Trade Copier - As Low as 0.00001
https://www.stevehopwoodforex.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?t=5595		 Page 4 of 16
Author:  cozybooks [ Thu Feb 14, 2019 1:00 pm ]
Post subject:  Ditto - Empty4 to Oanda Trade Copier - As Low as 0.00001
Problems continue with new version. I just checked and I now have three 300 unit sell trades on GBPUSD.

Thanks,
Steve
Author:  Jonah [ Thu Feb 14, 2019 2:31 pm ]
Post subject:  Ditto - Empty4 to Oanda Trade Copier - As Low as 0.00001
I will have some time this weekend and will get these issues fixed.
Author:  BigRunner [ Thu Feb 14, 2019 8:21 pm ]
Post subject:  Ditto - Empty4 to Oanda Trade Copier - As Low as 0.00001
Good luck to you, Lonnie! Hopefully, you can find that work/life balance and enjoy what you do for a living. That would be optimal.

It looks like you are already aware, but there are some issues with the new version. I tested it last night, and here is my experience in case it helps.

I installed the new ditto.exe and refreshed my Empty4 platform. Then I reset my grid trading EA. I returned to my terminal 12 hours later to see that ditto link was shut down, probably due to the repeat FIFO error messages. The EURUSD pair opened 5 short positions at the same lot size. The grid EA closed positions on the retracements, but the positions were not FIFO compliant. The "Increase each trade by one unit (US FIFO)" was set to "True," but Ditto did not increase the lot size on any of the EURUSD positions that were subsequently opened.

Once again, thank you for working on this.
Author:  Jonah [ Mon Feb 18, 2019 5:48 am ]
Post subject:  Ditto - Empty4 to Oanda Trade Copier - As Low as 0.00001
BigRunner » Thu Feb 14, 2019 12:21 pm wrote:Good luck to you, Lonnie! Hopefully, you can find that work/life balance and enjoy what you do for a living. That would be optimal.

It looks like you are already aware, but there are some issues with the new version. I tested it last night, and here is my experience in case it helps.

I installed the new ditto.exe and refreshed my Empty4 platform. Then I reset my grid trading EA. I returned to my terminal 12 hours later to see that ditto link was shut down, probably due to the repeat FIFO error messages. The EURUSD pair opened 5 short positions at the same lot size. The grid EA closed positions on the retracements, but the positions were not FIFO compliant. The "Increase each trade by one unit (US FIFO)" was set to "True," but Ditto did not increase the lot size on any of the EURUSD positions that were subsequently opened.

Once again, thank you for working on this.
I believe that I have fixed the calculation once and for all and have uploaded a new version. The Oanda API names trades with an underscore between currencies while Empty4 does not. I forgot to account for this when calculating lot sizes. Please test and let me know.
Author:  cozybooks [ Mon Feb 18, 2019 11:43 am ]
Post subject:  Ditto - Empty4 to Oanda Trade Copier - As Low as 0.00001
Lonnie, you are the best! One trade opened in the first minutes since installing the update. So far, so good!

Steve
Author:  BigRunner [ Wed Feb 20, 2019 6:11 am ]
Post subject:  Ditto - Empty4 to Oanda Trade Copier - As Low as 0.00001
Thank you for the update!

It seems to be working very good now and improved.

I may have done something out of order with the EA, but I noticed my EA was set to open 0.05 lot sizes and ditto set at 10%. It continued opening 400 units, which were positions still on Empty4 that were previously opened by the EA. I think that I changed the magic number when I reset the EA. I manually closed those positions in fxTrade (4-5 UJ buy positions).

Then I restarted my EA in Empty4 with 0.05 lot sizes and Ditto still set to open trades in fxTrade at 10%. I thought (incorrectly) that Ditto may close the positions to match fxTrade. Duh (long day, I'm tired, and my brain synapses are misfiring). Anyhow, Ditto opened several positions to match Empty4, which is probably the correct logic. It opened them in sequential order 400, 401, 402, 403, 404, and 405. YESSSS!!! That part now works! LDH5 (Long Distance High Five)!

The only thing is that the EA opened a new 0.05 lot position, so I was expecting Ditto to open up a 500 lot position. Actually, there was already a 0.05 lot opened in Empty4 from the previous EA session, so the lot should have been 501. Regardless, I'm still very pleased with the update!


:good:


Next Day Edit: I closed all of the USDJPY positions in Empty4. The EA is still running and one position is opened and being managed by it. The Ditto Dashboard is still showing 6 USDJPY positions even though there is only one each in my Empty4 and fxTrade account. The Magic Number of Ditto.exe is set to "0."
Author:  cozybooks [ Wed Feb 20, 2019 10:22 am ]
Post subject:  Ditto - Empty4 to Oanda Trade Copier - As Low as 0.00001
Overall, spectacular results, but I had one strange setup as well.

Dittolink or the Ditto EA stopped working overnight on my main account (it doesn't seem like it could have anything to do with running 10 Empty4 platforms and 5 dittolinks at once on one workstation :) but I suppose you never know.

The regular EA's were running just fine on the main account, so they opened four buy trades on AUDUSD while Ditto wasn't working. Because this was a new EA I was working on and somebody made a boo boo on just one teensy-weensy line of code, instead of lot sizes of .01, the lot sizes were opened as .01, .02, .04 and .08 (it was supposed to be matching the total sell lot size in determining the buy lot size, but instead kept matching the total buy lot size, in effect doubling with each trade - yikes!).

So I restarted the Empty4 platform and restarted dittolink. It immediately opened four new AUDUSD trades to match the new trades on the Empty4 platform. My ditto percent was 10%, but all four trades were opened at the 100 series instead of 100, 200, 400 and 800.

Wild stab in the dark - I'm wondering if multiple trades get opened by dittolink in one shot, if only the lot size of the first one is used - in my case this would have been a 100 series trade, rather than the individual lot sizes of each trade.

I tried opening another trade manually at .02 after that, and it correctly assigned it the next number in the 200 series.

Lonnie, thanks, great work!!! :clap: :clap: :clap:

Steve
Author:  BigRunner [ Wed Feb 20, 2019 6:08 pm ]
Post subject:  Ditto - Empty4 to Oanda Trade Copier - As Low as 0.00001
cozybooks » Today, 4:22 am wrote:Overall, spectacular results, but I had one strange setup as well.

...

So I restarted the Empty4 platform and restarted dittolink. It immediately opened four new AUDUSD trades to match the new trades on the Empty4 platform. My ditto percent was 10%, but all four trades were opened at the 100 series instead of 100, 200, 400 and 800.

Wild stab in the dark - I'm wondering if multiple trades get opened by dittolink in one shot, if only the lot size of the first one is used - in my case this would have been a 100 series trade, rather than the individual lot sizes of each trade.

I tried opening another trade manually at .02 after that, and it correctly assigned it the next number in the 200 series.

Lonnie, thanks, great work!!! :clap: :clap: :clap:

Steve

Good guess, Steve. That seems to match my experience as well. Thanks for providing the feedback for Jonah. It's encouraging to see at least two of us are actively testing this unique EA that allows maximum lot size flexibility with the OANDA broker.

I'm just wondering, Are there any other members out there testing the Ditto/Ditto Link combo?
Author:  jackneveu [ Wed Feb 20, 2019 7:43 pm ]
Post subject:  Ditto - Empty4 to Oanda Trade Copier - As Low as 0.00001
BigRunner » Wed Feb 20, 2019 1:08 pm wrote:
Good guess, Steve. That seems to match my experience as well. Thanks for providing the feedback for Jonah. It's encouraging to see at least two of us are actively testing this unique EA that allows maximum lot size flexibility with the OANDA broker.

I'm just wondering, Are there any other members out there testing the Ditto/Ditto Link combo?
Hi everyone.
I'm also giving it a go on a tiny account just to see the execution. So far so good. I'll let you guys know if there are any hitches.
Author:  BigRunner [ Thu Feb 21, 2019 2:56 am ]
Post subject:  Ditto - Empty4 to Oanda Trade Copier - As Low as 0.00001
jackneveu » Today, 1:43 pm wrote:
BigRunner » Wed Feb 20, 2019 1:08 pm wrote:
Good guess, Steve. That seems to match my experience as well. Thanks for providing the feedback for Jonah. It's encouraging to see at least two of us are actively testing this unique EA that allows maximum lot size flexibility with the OANDA broker.

I'm just wondering, Are there any other members out there testing the Ditto/Ditto Link combo?
Hi everyone.
I'm also giving it a go on a tiny account just to see the execution. So far so good. I'll let you guys know if there are any hitches.
Thanks and Welcome!

There is at least three of us now! =)

Ditto is perfect for tiny accounts.
All times are UTC Page 4 of 16

Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Limited