stevehopwoodforex.com
https://www.stevehopwoodforex.com/phpBB3/
Print view

Multi 10:4 Trader EA
https://www.stevehopwoodforex.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?t=1619		 Page 38 of 160
Author:  TraderDesk [ Mon Mar 25, 2013 9:53 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Multi 10:4 Trader EA
MrLong wrote:
This EA needs managing, by the trader.

If we had an EA that just made money, then that EA would be a money machine and everyone would be wealthy, nice thought, but will not happen.

Anyone who thinks an EA can be dropped on a chart and the trader who dropped it, can steam down the road to the pub, have a few beers come home and his account is up 2-3 % up is kidding him/her self on.

Andy
So true... There has been many hedge funds staff with experts that collapse because their black box could not change with the markets.... An EA on a Empty4 platform will not do better. Now what it will do is give a trader a solid platform to work on to become more successful with their bottom line.

Andy is there an easier way to include or exclude currencies traded on 10.4? For example I may want to trade 4 or 5 currencies or even just one. Can there be an option that is the opposite of

"extern string IgnorePair = ""; // place symbol if you want to ignore

like

"extern string TradingPair = ""; // place symbol if you want to trade

Also I had talked about this before but I know that Bob is using this in conjunction with 10.4 - Is there a way that 10.4 can look at the output of the CCS indicator an trade the strongest 1,2,3 currencies against the weakest 1,2,3? I really like it and it works...

When 10.4 puts a pending order and it is triggered is there a way to have it place another pending one level preceding the original pending. Example: Pending sell stop at 121.7 trigger at Weekly Support 1 and new pending Sell Limit placed at Weekly Mid Support 1. If price action goes up to that level the pending Sell Limit is trigger...

I wish I knew how to program as I would jump in there with you guys... :)
Author:  SWG123 [ Mon Mar 25, 2013 10:02 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Multi 10:4 Trader EA
TraderDesk wrote:Andy is there an easier way to include or exclude currencies traded on 10.4? For example I may want to trade 4 or 5 currencies or even just one. Can there be an option that is the opposite of

"extern string IgnorePair = ""; // place symbol if you want to ignore

like

"extern string TradingPair = ""; // place symbol if you want to trade
I was wondering this too. Can we just edit Market Watch and set AutomaticSymbolScan=True?
Author:  MrLong [ Mon Mar 25, 2013 10:18 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Multi 10:4 Trader EA
TraderDesk wrote:
MrLong wrote:
This EA needs managing, by the trader.

If we had an EA that just made money, then that EA would be a money machine and everyone would be wealthy, nice thought, but will not happen.

Anyone who thinks an EA can be dropped on a chart and the trader who dropped it, can steam down the road to the pub, have a few beers come home and his account is up 2-3 % up is kidding him/her self on.

Andy
So true... There has been many hedge funds staff with experts that collapse because their black box could not change with the markets.... An EA on a Empty4 platform will not do better. Now what it will do is give a trader a solid platform to work on to become more successful with their bottom line.

Andy is there an easier way to include or exclude currencies traded on 10.4? For example I may want to trade 4 or 5 currencies or even just one. Can there be an option that is the opposite of

"extern string IgnorePair = ""; // place symbol if you want to ignore

like

"extern string TradingPair = ""; // place symbol if you want to trade

Also I had talked about this before but I know that Bob is using this in conjunction with 10.4 - Is there a way that 10.4 can look at the output of the CCS indicator an trade the strongest 1,2,3 currencies against the weakest 1,2,3? I really like it and it works...

When 10.4 puts a pending order and it is triggered is there a way to have it place another pending one level preceding the original pending. Example: Pending sell stop at 121.7 trigger at Weekly Support 1 and new pending Sell Limit placed at Weekly Mid Support 1. If price action goes up to that level the pending Sell Limit is trigger...

I wish I knew how to program as I would jump in there with you guys... :)
I've been down the road before, where we add this and add that, before long the EA is not what it started out to be, I've tried all the strength stuff before and for me it never worked, if you look at a chart and see that when price is below the Monthly 2ma, it continues, we just have to be patient, the EA is working fine, so why change it, but I do valid your idea's.

If price pulls back and the condition is correct to place orders, the EA will do what you are asking.

Best Regards
Andy



Best Regards
Andy
Author:  MrLong [ Mon Mar 25, 2013 10:24 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Multi 10:4 Trader EA
SWG123 wrote:
TraderDesk wrote:Andy is there an easier way to include or exclude currencies traded on 10.4? For example I may want to trade 4 or 5 currencies or even just one. Can there be an option that is the opposite of

"extern string IgnorePair = ""; // place symbol if you want to ignore

like

"extern string TradingPair = ""; // place symbol if you want to trade
I was wondering this too. Can we just edit Market Watch and set AutomaticSymbolScan=True?

Hello,
AutomaticSymbolScan=True, floods the screen with all the symbols.

Are you looking at something like only trade these pairs, like Paul's EA do?

Andy
Author:  SWG123 [ Mon Mar 25, 2013 10:36 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Multi 10:4 Trader EA
MrLong wrote:
SWG123 wrote:
TraderDesk wrote:Andy is there an easier way to include or exclude currencies traded on 10.4? For example I may want to trade 4 or 5 currencies or even just one. Can there be an option that is the opposite of

"extern string IgnorePair = ""; // place symbol if you want to ignore

like

"extern string TradingPair = ""; // place symbol if you want to trade
I was wondering this too. Can we just edit Market Watch and set AutomaticSymbolScan=True?

Hello,
AutomaticSymbolScan=True, floods the screen with all the symbols.

Are you looking at something like only trade these pairs, like Paul's EA do?

Andy
Yes, exactly. :)
Author:  Wkcfx [ Mon Mar 25, 2013 10:45 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Multi 10:4 Trader EA
MrLong wrote:
I've been down the road before, where we add this and add that, before long the EA is not what it started out to be, I've tried all the strength stuff before and for me it never worked, if you look at a chart and see that when price is below the Monthly 2ma, it continues, we just have to be patient, the EA is working fine, so why change it, but I do valid your idea's.

If price pulls back and the condition is correct to place orders, the EA will do what you are asking.

Best Regards
Andy



Best Regards
Andy

Thanks MrLong and all who are working so hard on this. After sorting out my CPU issue, thanks Slipshod, Snailbeard and all, i kicked off 1.08 Stoch/RSI Monday AM Asia, results attached.

All the Best
Bill
Author:  MrLong [ Mon Mar 25, 2013 10:52 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Multi 10:4 Trader EA
SWG123 wrote:
MrLong wrote:
SWG123 wrote:
TraderDesk wrote:Andy is there an easier way to include or exclude currencies traded on 10.4? For example I may want to trade 4 or 5 currencies or even just one. Can there be an option that is the opposite of

"extern string IgnorePair = ""; // place symbol if you want to ignore

like

"extern string TradingPair = ""; // place symbol if you want to trade
I was wondering this too. Can we just edit Market Watch and set AutomaticSymbolScan=True?

Hello,
AutomaticSymbolScan=True, floods the screen with all the symbols.

Are you looking at something like only trade these pairs, like Paul's EA do?

Andy
Yes, exactly. :)
Ok, as soon as the E A is working without any problems, we can add all the extras..

Thanks for all your feedback

Andy
Author:  snailbeard [ Mon Mar 25, 2013 10:59 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Multi 10:4 Trader EA
duplicate post :oops:
Author:  Jonathan2FI [ Mon Mar 25, 2013 11:48 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Multi 10:4 Trader EA
Andy, and potentially other 10.4 experts who trade end of day,

1.07 doing well 2% up on Monday trading with some "intelligent" intervention against 1% risk trades. I take your point on keeping EA pure to 10.4 strategy and not adding rules and complexity to seemingly refine selection ...it generally does not work I have developed EAs and thought I was being cleaver to identify unsuccessful trades and programme them out only to end up with ....nothing. A successful mechanical trading strategy has a small window of opportunity which can easily be destroyed by over development with automation and complexity. Plus leave the detailed trade management side to individuals and their individual risk appetite and or philosophy of the markets to define.
On this last point I need some advice ..even with equity protection EA, vps running with secure provider in NY, and 1% risk, plus less aggressive settings ref. correlation, exit on reversal, use both for pull back.... I still would like to prevent significant equity retracement during the period I cannot normally intervene (new day job 8am -8pm GMT ) I am disciplined to review every evening 2200 GMT for one hour so what to use .....MPTM and or MPBM conflicts ? experience? application ? or just leave it with stealth?

Secondly tried 1.08 did not fire up nothing inside borders ...must try harder before whingeing leave it with me unless you have any intuition...

Last point what is the consensus on RSI Vs. Stoch??? use one or the other or both? anything concrete?

Thanks in advance
Jonathan
Author:  mobthehop [ Tue Mar 26, 2013 2:06 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Multi 10:4 Trader EA
Jonathan, NB recently stated in his thread that he generally prefers Rsi on TMA over Stoch.... but he also mentioned that he uses RSI on H4 and Stoch on H1. Not able to quickly locate the original post but here is a subsequent one - http://www.stevehopwoodforex.com/phpBB3 ... 599#p48599

Cheers
All times are UTC Page 38 of 160

Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Limited