stevehopwoodforex.com
https://www.stevehopwoodforex.com/phpBB3/
Print view

MADTrader
https://www.stevehopwoodforex.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?t=4590
Page 45 of 92
Author:  919gilead [ Fri Mar 11, 2016 5:10 pm ]
Post subject:  MAD-EA

Wavegarrick » Fri Mar 11, 2016 9:58 am wrote:So,

Between only 3 trades opened for the day not a bad days work with over 200 pips in a short space of time...the choice is yours if you want to hold for the longer term swing....especially when all I have done is type here all day long :smile:

Take care Guys have a great weekend....
Thanks Leon, this is all we need - remove the risk from the trades and let the ATM run :yahoo:

Have a great & refreshing week end.
Author:  919gilead [ Fri Mar 11, 2016 5:15 pm ]
Post subject:  MAD-EA

jren » Fri Mar 11, 2016 9:23 am wrote:
When I woke up this morning which was about 15 minutes after the ECB news conference started, net pips for the trades on my laptop were about 150+ pips and within 15 minutes, the profit was wiped off and the losses started mounting. As I looked at the reversal, I asked myself one question, if this were to be a live account, will you allow 150 pip profit turn into a 150+ pip loss. The answer was obvious and I closed all the trades manually leaving a net loss of 207 pips for the day. The EA refreshed and took new trades based on the new signals and within 25 minutes made 395 pip profit and the position was reversed.
How about having MPTM watch this for you?
Thanks Jren. My 1st goal was to achieve a consistently profitable EA (trade) entry setting and now that I have achieved that, I am working on the exit strategy and MPTM setting will definitely be one of them.

Shalom :hi:
Author:  Wavegarrick [ Fri Mar 11, 2016 5:17 pm ]
Post subject:  MAD-EA

Thanks George u too Buddy :good:

By the way I hope i am not bonkers but after all I am a Mad trader :clap:
Author:  919gilead [ Fri Mar 11, 2016 5:18 pm ]
Post subject:  MAD-EA

Wavegarrick » Fri Mar 11, 2016 10:17 am wrote:Thanks George u too Buddy :good:

By the way I hope i am not bonkers but after all I am a Mad trader :clap:
No you're not as I am also an "MADDY" trader :good:
Author:  Bippo [ Fri Mar 11, 2016 6:24 pm ]
Post subject:  MAD-EA

Wavegarrick » Fri Mar 11, 2016 9:35 am wrote:Hi Guys,

Through a log.......
Anyway guys all I have time for now please feel free to ask questions...this whole process is really very simple and a great piece of work by Rene and George....I think some of us are just making it more complex than what it really is..

Tc
wow,that's what I call a post :clap:
I'm even thinkin ' to point it out to a puzzled Trader that is not fully understanding MADDY Indicator behaviour.

And look at this thread,25 posts in a Day !
Author:  bazze [ Fri Mar 11, 2016 7:05 pm ]
Post subject:  MAD-EA

Wishing all the MAD boys and gals in here a great weekend :party:
Author:  passgo [ Fri Mar 11, 2016 11:45 pm ]
Post subject:  MAD-EA

First of all, I have been following for some time and my thanks to all who have created this tool are well overdue - thank you! As I see it, this is performing brilliantly and doesn't need more and more tweaks. The fundamental question for the EA is can we identify when to turn it off and can we automate that? Until then, the low risk option is to manage regularly manually and follow the news calendar. I feel it out performs my ability to trade manually and really it is not possible to ask for more than that from an EA.

Two thoughts - I experienced the sudden reversal a couple of weeks ago but was away from my platform so didn't see it happen or how the dashboard behaved. I am not sure whether there is any way to simulate with back testing. Was there a moment where a certain number of currencies had flipped from strong to weak or visa versa which would have signalled a "black swan" event and could have closed all positions, preventing larger losses, and switched off until the dashboard had completed a re-balancing?

My other thought is more out of the box and might be too complex although experience tells me that if it is a good idea, with work a simple way will evolve. MAD is handling a mass of data - can we go one step further and simulate how the future should look? As soon as there is a deviation from that future, something has happened - this could be used as an automatic signal and it would be up to the trader to decide what level of deviation triggers close and shut down. Alternatively, it can be a manual signal and then possible to review, identify the cause, take action and trade accordingly - close, hedge etc.

Hope these comments are helpful - if not please file accordingly :uff:
Author:  jiaxingx [ Sat Mar 12, 2016 1:56 am ]
Post subject:  MAD-EA

hi,ren
the parameter " TimeBetweenTrades" is calculate by previous trade 's opentimes or closetimes?

thanks.
:)
Author:  renexxxx [ Sat Mar 12, 2016 2:22 am ]
Post subject:  MAD-EA

jiaxingx » Sat Mar 12, 2016 11:56 am wrote:hi,ren
the parameter " TimeBetweenTrades" is calculate by previous trade 's opentimes or closetimes?

thanks.
:)
The parameter TimeBetweenTrades, is the time (in seconds), the EA needs to wait after a previous trade of a particular symbol was closed, before a new trade for that same symbol can be opened. So, yes, it looks at the OrderCloseTime() of the previous trade of the same symbol.
Author:  TraderJoeForex [ Sat Mar 12, 2016 7:06 am ]
Post subject:  MAD-EA

I also agree that this tool is performing brilliantly and with the developments that a few of us are testing behind the scenes as I have said already there really are so many ways to trade this thing.

George and Leon are both correct with their different approaches and both making lots of pips with tried and tested strategy in their own way using this tool which is what this is about.

There is a lot of talk about pullbacks and the question is when does a pullback become a reversal on the timeframe you are trading and what risk and trade management settings will you use to deal with it? If you are trading a longer timeframe then yes you will get caught at the end but after making 1000pips with trades into the trend you accept the 200 you must give back at the end each time with pleasure. Of course if this just happens to be your first live trade with the wrong money management it could also be your last and your perspective would be very different! Equally on a shorter term strategy a 200pip loss would never be acceptable so where do you draw the line in the sand?

When the conditions which created our trade entry are no longer present how long do we want to stay in the trade? If price has broken a trendline against our trade at an area of support / resistance or the lower timeframe MA's are crossing back then we must get out whether we are in profit or loss. Then we will be ready to trade the next signal and George gave a great example of this a few pages back where early losses were quickly turned into profits when a pullback became a reversal and he caught the new moves.

Perhaps it is time to start discussing exits in more detail and lets post some chart examples next week whether profit or loss and whether manual or trade manager. It will be interesting to see and compare how the more experienced people here are closing their pips and I think this will help everyone else on this thread since the original brief of using this tool to get great entries is now pretty much nailed whatever your trading style.

Have a great weekend everyone.
All times are UTC Page 45 of 92