Holy Graily Bob 'n Grid

[xfactornos]

I hope I dont get bitch slapped for posting this, but this is my results so far with version 1V. and the real version 1V. about 40 versions ago...

[cyberevil]

I'm running experimental and HGBnG side by side and the results on experimental are just mental compared to HGBnG. Just looking at AUDUSD shoot down at the moment and I will close it manually once it hits or comes close to previous support area.

[traderandy]

I agree my demo results are all much better using the experimental version.. I am in the process of setting up a Global Prime and hope to be going live next week.

A very big thank you for everyone's contributions.

[heart1010]

@Steve
Is it possible that your "Pause Trading" button is without any effect?

The check(s) for "TradingPaused" variable are missing (at bottom in onTick() for example), aren't they?

Code: Select all

   //Trading
   if(EveryTickMode) OldBarsTime=0;
   if (!TradingPaused) // <- this is missing!!?   
   if(OldBarsTime!=iTime(NULL,TradingTimeFrame,0))
   {
      OldBarsTime = iTime(NULL, TradingTimeFrame, 0);
      //ReadIndicatorValues();//Remember to delete the call higher up in this function if EveryTickMode = false
      if (TimeCurrent() >= TimeToStartTrading)
         if (!StopTrading) ....

...also in ShouldTradesBeClosed() the check(s) are missing!?

[SteveHopwood]

@Steve
Is it possible that your "Pause Trading" button is without any effect?

The check(s) for "TradingPaused" variable are missing (at bottom in onTick() for example), aren't they?

Code: Select all

   //Trading
   if(EveryTickMode) OldBarsTime=0;
   if (!TradingPaused) // <- this is missing!!?   
   if(OldBarsTime!=iTime(NULL,TradingTimeFrame,0))
   {
      OldBarsTime = iTime(NULL, TradingTimeFrame, 0);
      //ReadIndicatorValues();//Remember to delete the call higher up in this function if EveryTickMode = false
      if (TimeCurrent() >= TimeToStartTrading)
         if (!StopTrading) ....

...also in ShouldTradesBeClosed() the check(s) are missing!?

Nice spot. Thanks. I am not going to do anything about it now, but will do in time for next week.

Should it be in ShouldTradesBeClosed()? Not sure. This is a management function, so I am not sure if we want to interrupt grid replacements. I need to think about that.

[traderduke]

my results show that BnG Experimental both with Bobs MA & without wins hands down over the straight BnG.

2016-04-07_204146-BnG regular.png

2016-04-07_204547-v1q-exp-ootb.png

2016-04-07_202855-v1q-exp-wbobMA.png

Steve
I can see why your dropping regular BnG. Just looking at the programming gives me a head ache. I don't how you keep up with it.

Best Regards
Ray

[oliverjp]

Hi Ray

Thanks for sharing interesting and useful results.

May I enquire please what that nifty Equity monitor indicator is that you are using in the bottom chart window? And do you find the equity graph it produces fairly accurate?

Regards

Jeff

[traderduke]

Hi Ray

Thanks for sharing interesting and useful results.

May I enquire please what that nifty Equity monitor indicator is that you are using in the bottom chart window? And do you find the equity graph it produces fairly accurate?

Regards

Jeff

jeff
Its Renexxxx's creation, Its accurate to the dollar, It reads the "account history". Great for tracking the ups & DDs.

Have fun

Ray
PS: I love your avatar, I dived for 40 years.

http://www.stevehopwoodforex.com/phpBB3 ... tradechart

[Lifesys]

Have not even looked at 'Experimental' Steve! The current party is so much fun. I watch interestingly the ebb & flow of ideas. Ran HGBnG in various versions parallel (usually a few versions behind) until I find one better. Drop History results via CSV into Pivot table analyser.
Orig. v1z, v2L & v3M (I call it 3 not to confuse with original v1z which was outstanding) are by far the best. The success rate has increased with each of these.
This account, also running TMP_PipSmasher v5 (very good) has grown 159% since 2nd week of Feb.

2016-04-08_221912.png

Note: the dips in the graph are when DD got too much for me & I closed everything. Takes a couple of days to recover but always back with vigour, higher than before. Simply amazing & outstrips any manual or other EA I have seen. Account floated ~ -19% last Thurs then Tuesday rose from -19% DD to all banked (0% DD) in one night (Lond session).
Now running HGBnG v3M live on 19 pairs (no buttons as I have those functions in a Script.) Hit 4% closeoff target each of last 2 days. HGBnG will never be perfect, but handle like a reactive F1 car & it does extraordinary things. What a team!!

[TraderJoeForex]

I have had the experimental version on live cent account test this week with Trend Arrow only and even with ridiculous cent account spreads has done well. It will be on my main live Global Prime account next week.

..............not a bad finish for the week, H4 Trend Arrow only

Brilliant work people.