HGI used with Hurst charts

Includes an archive of all previous Bob stuff
Post Reply
User avatar
TraderJoeForex
Trader
Posts: 1157
Joined: Fri Mar 08, 2013 10:29 pm
Location: South London

HGI used with Hurst charts

Post by TraderJoeForex »

Centrefix » Tue Feb 17, 2015 9:14 am wrote:Hi TraderJoe,

With respect to your NZDUSD trade this morning on the 15 min, and others to come, I am just trying to see if I have the entry criteria correct:

1/ Signal from the wavy, at least one DL MACD HURST red (for short).

2/ Entry on first candle open following a validated wavy where the open is outside the current time frame white 5TMA. (Below for longs and above for shorts).

I only write to clarify I have this correct. Is this the only interpretation you are making at the moment to system?

Many thanks.

Matt

Hey Matt, yes that is corrrect although I am finding rule 2 above is keeping me out of most H4 opportunities so far this week so I need too look at this further but fine on M15. Also I am thinking a 10pip TP on M15 and 50pip on H4 might work welll rather than waiting for the opposite signal as I have exited early a few times and glad I did.
User avatar
TraderJoeForex
Trader
Posts: 1157
Joined: Fri Mar 08, 2013 10:29 pm
Location: South London

HGI used with Hurst charts

Post by TraderJoeForex »

Here's another M15 trade on EURAUD ... I was slightly late and missed the open so price already through 5TMA but final leg down on an M so a fairly safe bet.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
User avatar
TraderJoeForex
Trader
Posts: 1157
Joined: Fri Mar 08, 2013 10:29 pm
Location: South London

HGI used with Hurst charts

Post by TraderJoeForex »

TraderJoeForex » Tue Feb 17, 2015 4:58 pm wrote:Here's another M15 trade on EURAUD ... I was slightly late and missed the open so price already through 5TMA but final leg down on an M so a fairly safe bet.
..out now for +19pips on this one.
Centrefix

HGI used with Hurst charts

Post by Centrefix »

Hi TraderJoe,

Thanks for answering my questions and hope you don't mind if I ask a couple more as it goes a long way to homing in on the goal of getting something concrete that works.

Concentrating on the 15m time frame for the moment: I have found occasional disparity between the wavy signal being generated from the matrix template (using HGI16.04) and the chart I open when a signal is generated. Oddly enough when I deleted HGI16.04 from the 15m chart template and then re-added it there is more consistency so wondered if there is a setting somewhere that may have been saved in the template.

That anomaly aside, once a wavy signal is generated and the corresponding chart opened, do you enter the trade immediately at the next bar open price, provided the rules of TMA and MACD are respected?

Many thanks for all your help..

Matt
User avatar
TraderJoeForex
Trader
Posts: 1157
Joined: Fri Mar 08, 2013 10:29 pm
Location: South London

HGI used with Hurst charts

Post by TraderJoeForex »

Centrefix » Tue Feb 17, 2015 8:52 pm wrote:Hi TraderJoe,

Thanks for answering my questions and hope you don't mind if I ask a couple more as it goes a long way to homing in on the goal of getting something concrete that works.

Concentrating on the 15m time frame for the moment: I have found occasional disparity between the wavy signal being generated from the matrix template (using HGI16.04) and the chart I open when a signal is generated. Oddly enough when I deleted HGI16.04 from the 15m chart template and then re-added it there is more consistency so wondered if there is a setting somewhere that may have been saved in the template.

That anomaly aside, once a wavy signal is generated and the corresponding chart opened, do you enter the trade immediately at the next bar open price, provided the rules of TMA and MACD are respected?

Many thanks for all your help..

Matt
Yes I have found the same disparity between 16.04 15min and MATRIX .. I think it may relate to some of the tweeks made for the 15min version which is stlil beta so maybe I shouldn't have posted this. If taking signals from the MATRIX don't really need 16.04 on the chart anyway - I just have it there when posting a chart.

Happy to answer your questions and glad I can potentially help someone. It is others help that has got me this far.

I do enter the trade immediately at the next bar open provided rules of TMA and MACD are respected and I would say the TMA rule is only important from a point of view of getting a reasonable entry.

However I am also currently trying an alternative which is to use a 5TMA band rather than centerline and then the entry would be a pending order at the band to give a better entry than the candle open (0.61 band seems to work well being close enough to price action this is 61% of the pair's ATR).

I would say getting comfortable with entries at the candle open is the first step though and then look at what posibilities there are to fine tune further.

I am finding M15 offers loads of opportunities - a consistent 20-30pips per day from 2 - 3 trades shouldn't be too much of a challenge just on this timeframe. Just stay out during news.

FYI on H4 and higher I think just using wavies with TDMTL break will give more entries and am back to practising with this now as per earlier posts in this thread. [19/2 EDIT - no I was just being impatient.. taking entry under the 5TMA is definately what we want for best risk/reward.. ]
Last edited by TraderJoeForex on Thu Feb 19, 2015 8:47 am, edited 1 time in total.
Centrefix

HGI used with Hurst charts

Post by Centrefix »

Hi,
Thanks very much for your reply. I will keep focusing on those 15min setups and see how things progress. Looking forward to hearing of your developments with this as well. Any fine tuning for entries is more icing on the cake as far as I am concerned as already this is a great collection of tools.
I think I will just take the matrix wavy signals as they occur irrespective of whether the HGI 16.04 displays the same. Be interested to hear how others are finding this too.
Best regards,

Matt
zyx
Trader
Posts: 84
Joined: Thu Jan 29, 2015 12:42 am
Location: San Diego

HGI used with Hurst charts

Post by zyx »

TJF, why is your MACD so smooth? Mine is blocky. If I set it up on a M15 chart but with a 240 TF it will only move in blocks of 16 lines.
SWG123
Trader
Posts: 565
Joined: Wed Nov 16, 2011 3:02 pm
Location: Cape Town

HGI used with Hurst charts

Post by SWG123 »

zyx » Wed Feb 18, 2015 6:04 pm wrote:TJF, why is your MACD so smooth? Mine is blocky. If I set it up on a M15 chart but with a 240 TF it will only move in blocks of 16 lines.
And 240 divided by 15 = ?
zyx
Trader
Posts: 84
Joined: Thu Jan 29, 2015 12:42 am
Location: San Diego

HGI used with Hurst charts

Post by zyx »

Dude you scared me, I thought I did my math wrong.

I'm curious why TJF's curves are completely smooth
spotdespot
Trader
Posts: 768
Joined: Sun Jan 22, 2012 11:38 pm

HGI used with Hurst charts

Post by spotdespot »

zyx » Wed Feb 18, 2015 5:27 pm wrote:Dude you scared me, I thought I did my math wrong.

I'm curious why TJF's curves are completely smooth
It's because he doesn't use the MTF MACD - he just uses larger TMA slow and fast levels on the current TF version. Read back in the thread a bit - they don't map to H4 equivalent anyway if I remember correctly.
Post Reply

Return to “Nanningbob's Holy Grail Indicator forum”