Account analysis by magic number

[fode]

Hi,

Is there a utility that can help to analyse historical trades by magic number ? e.g. NB10.2 has D1 Trend, H4 Trend, etc. If that can be displayed in pie chart, that will be great.

thanks

[AnotherBrian]

Hi,

Is there a utility that can help to analyse historical trades by magic number ? e.g. NB10.2 has D1 Trend, H4 Trend, etc. If that can be displayed in pie chart, that will be great.

thanks

MyFxbook lets you do something like that, I never used it though, but you can filter by magic.

[fode]

I just tried myfxbook, but I think NB10.2 magic is 0 for all trades, I think I have to use the "comment" in the Account History instead of magic, any advise please ?

[mrpipstrader]

Hi fode,

Try http://www.mt4i.com . Click on the "Stats" button and there's a tab, labelled "Strategy", which sorts by magic number or comment. I remember using this about 12 months ago to do exactly what you're asking.

Cheers
mrpipstrader

[fode]

Thank you for your suggestion. MT4i can categorise trades by magic numbers.

New challenge for me now is to find out / tie back the comments to the magic number, but I am confused about some comments vis magic numbers e.g. two trades with the same comment BB Range[tp] has two different magic numbers 1776929364 and 602744331 ?

Is there an automatic way to tie back the magic number and the comments ?

Appreciate to shed some light about the different magic number for the same comment ?

[ross]

You could try this...

[fode]

Hi Ross,

thank you for your xls. May I know how to export account history into csv file so that it can be imported to this xls ?

thanks