3,540,000% gain within a year with just $500!

scheinwerfer
Trader
Posts: 42
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2011 12:36 am

Re: 3,540,000% gain within a year with just $500!

Post by scheinwerfer »

BS7 is history as it seems, there's a new one, can be tracked here ->http://www.fxstat.com/en/performances/v ... Sale-14181
Broker still unknown...
garyfritz

Re: 3,540,000% gain within a year with just $500!

Post by garyfritz »

99%+ wins. Seems pretty unlikely to me, but who knows. He uses 10 pip TP and 75 pip SL. By random chance you'd get about 88% wins. 11% more wins shouldn't be THAT hard, right?
User avatar
themaxx
Trader
Posts: 71
Joined: Thu May 24, 2012 9:57 am

Re: 3,540,000% gain within a year with just $500!

Post by themaxx »

scheinwerfer wrote:BS7 is history as it seems, there's a new one, can be tracked here ->http://www.fxstat.com/en/performances/v ... Sale-14181
criminal still unknown...
Looking at the trades - it looks like some kind of grid system? Also, as his open trades are private, he could have a number of trades that are deeply in the red, right? I'm not that familiar with fxstats, but if you look on the summary page under "Risk", the probability of 100% loss is 100%
Sylv1

Re: 3,540,000% gain within a year with just $500!

Post by Sylv1 »

This one :

http://www.fxstat.com/en/performances/v ... lper-12854

98.13% of accuracy on 7743 trades on 16 different pairs :shock:
scheinwerfer
Trader
Posts: 42
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2011 12:36 am

Re: 3,540,000% gain within a year with just $500!

Post by scheinwerfer »

themaxx wrote: Looking at the trades - it looks like some kind of grid system? Also, as his open trades are private, he could have a number of trades that are deeply in the red, right? I'm not that familiar with fxstats, but if you look on the summary page under "Risk", the probability of 100% loss is 100%
Quite possible, I'll contact them once more and try to make them sell the system, maybe a few bits of useful info will land in my lap. It's still more probable that their systems are fake, so further analysis is just a waste of time, just trying to cut my losses in that sense so to speak.
Last edited by scheinwerfer on Fri Jan 04, 2013 6:57 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
niepce
Trader
Posts: 152
Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2012 11:00 pm
Location: Grenoble, France

Re: 3,540,000% gain within a year with just $500!

Post by niepce »

Sylv1 wrote:This one :

http://www.fxstat.com/en/performances/v ... lper-12854

98.13% of accuracy on 7743 trades on 16 different pairs :shock:

Probably bullshit.
1 pip gains on demotrades ?
In real, remove increased spread, ordersend errors, slippage, .5 to .75 pip commission.

If i had a milliondollar making machine (or even a hundreddollar). First i won't talk about on forums, second, i would'nt talk about to nobody, third, i would'nt distribute the ex4, fourth, i wouldn't ask 49$ for the ex4.

As simple as 1234.

The thing can be d/l there http://worldwide-invest.org/threads/156 ... 15-scalper
jb68
Trader
Posts: 71
Joined: Mon Jan 30, 2012 11:30 pm

Re: 3,540,000% gain within a year with just $500!

Post by jb68 »

garyfritz wrote:I'd love to see you reverse-engineer it, even if you didn't get the full 94%-wins result.

And you don't need that many coding skills to do it. Reverse-engineering a system from its trades is NOT easy, but you can do it just by looking at charts and observing patterns: does he usually trade at a certain time? What's the setup? What's the trigger? If you think you've got it figured out, describe the behavior and I can put it into Tradestation and see if the backtest matches the myfxbook trade history.

One difficulty is that (assuming the trades are real) it's very possible the guy was trading discretionarily -- meaning he might not have been acting consistently, or he might have been trading several different types of signals. Sorting out the trades and determining which ones are from signal A and which from signal B can be very tricky, but you need to do it if you want to find the consistent patterns for each signal.

It might be easier to start with the EA report that eddysukses posted. That was apparently an EA, so at least that should be acting consistently. It still might have several unrelated entry signals but it should be easier to reverse-engineer than a human's trades.
Hi Garry,

The good news is there is a huge chance to be only one strategy here forward tested by that guy. There are some rules for sure, but:

First I would start with loses ..
SL is 40 pips.

Openings
Then there is only one trade at a time, most time alternating. This means something like a MA cross or ZZ.

Exits.
- fix TP of 40 after a SL is hit.

Duration - around 1 day so big TF.

Would be nice a script to load the trades from a txt file and plot on Empty4.
garyfritz

Re: 3,540,000% gain within a year with just $500!

Post by garyfritz »

First google hit on "plot trades Empty4" was http://www.forexfactory.com/showthread. ... ost4298192. Might help? If not, there are others...
Loustar1
Posts: 2
Joined: Thu Mar 08, 2012 4:39 pm

Re: 3,540,000% gain within a year with just $500!

Post by Loustar1 »

These are links to a couple of backtests and a small live test of one of the many systems by buddy and I put together some time ago. You will see that we had a high win rate that was offset by 100 or 200 pip stop(this is where my partner and I had major differences as to money management) while only taking profits of 7-8-9 or 9-10-11 pips.

It's quite possible to build a robust system with an excellent hit rate. The problem is finding a broker that will actually let you run it. We were told by two brokers (both now out of business) that we couldn't run our EA's on their platform. We were given a host of pure BS reasons for this and eventually dropped the matter and went ton to design things that would keep us under the radar and not get our account flagged. The brokers in question were IB's and I guess they had a hard time offsetting our trades. The statement in .doc format was done that way to hide the indicators and settings info that is usually at the top of the backtest. (My trading partner still wants to remain discreet) One statement is a live forward test of about a month or so - and one statement is from a small live account we ran before we went live with much larger starting balance. That was when the issues began with the brokers - not in the mood at the moment to re-live the entire soap opera but I will tell you it was a real eye opener to the working of many brokers. We will revisit several of the systems we created and tweak them for the new rules and regs and keep you posted. Our original ,programmer is no longer working with us so I will reach out the amazing minds here for some help when we are ready.

Comments questions welcome - and thanks Steve for creating a great forum for the serious minded trader.

Be well

Lou



https://mega.co.nz/#!VUt1yCaT!IVl7VCJdg ... veQlugX2Ao
https://mega.co.nz/#!FVMQHYha!TfywkCVbE ... 3_bSQ-MW3A
https://mega.co.nz/#!oMETRZrb!Q0LmXxBQJ ... 7WHYE68LuI
ianp
Trader
Posts: 83
Joined: Tue Nov 15, 2011 9:58 pm

Re: 3,540,000% gain within a year with just $500!

Post by ianp »

Loustar1 wrote: The problem is finding a broker that will actually let you run it.

Could you not have uses Interactive Brokers via there API or Dukascopy using the Empty4 bridge ?
Post Reply

Return to “Manual trading systems”