Macd Stochastic Fractal MA5/25 Daily Marylin

[vadlapatis]

can anyone advise? using set files posted a few pages back ,my equity yesterday was as high as £1368, my balance today is £856

what can you suggest to prevent such large losses?

may be avoid forex market

if you read my explanation post, you will know that's Marylin is a "trend catcher", and it's very difficult to avoid false signals, or as yesterday, big retracement.

Look in journal tab, and post the closed message to check your parameters.

but I remind everybody my ask :

Brain Storming request !

I never success to filter bad trade and good trade : they always look like to me similar at the beginning !
The only way to manage them it's to close them after a while.

For all of us who have trades since 2 weeks : please analyse each bad trade/good trade ! If you can see or add something to distinguish them.... please let me know !

Since I have shared this EA, I have not received any improvement...but a lot of claim

EURUSD GOOD TRADE and BAD TRADE look like similar to filter signals module.PNG

Mr. Phil

no doubt that our Marylin is a good EA which catches Huge PIPS with trend - but if we c the 3 EU orders closed at very less profit - even though we have a chance to collect huge pips. so we should not only think of big trend but also bank the huge pips which Marylin is catching.

Regards

Anil

[phil_trade]

Mr. Phil

no doubt that our Marylin is a good EA which catches Huge PIPS with trend - but if we c the 3 EU orders closed at very less profit - even though we have a chance to collect huge pips. so we should not only think of big trend but also bank the huge pips which Marylin is catching.

Regards

Anil

Why not, but if you can prove your assertion ! I have made a lot of test in ForexTester and the only way (i have found...may be there's another one) is to keep trade along trend. I am opened to all the suggetions and I can make the tests with FT over 4 years... so let's start a brain storming

keep this in mind please :

FT Benchmark 2009 2013 fixed lot 0.10.PNG

[phil_trade]

to confirm my opinion, look at this forward FT test of €/$ from 05/02/2013 to 31/03/2013

€-$ 02-2013 forward FT test.PNG

if you take to early your profit, you can't find another entry ( I have made a lot of test without success )

[sponn]

Ive just setup live account with Armada Markets using 0.01 using 0.35 and provided set files. I will post myfxbook link later. I have got aud/jpy short now

[spotdespot]

I think the reason you may not have had any responses regarding your brain storming for avoiding false signals Phil is that if anyone had a good answer it would "solve" most forex issues

Marylin looks pretty good to me so far (still early in testing of course). It is painful watching some of the big gains reverse but, as you have said, your impressive testing has shown that if we want those big trends then we just have to stick with it.

If I have any brainwaves for improvements I will post them!

Thanks,
Dave.

[phil_trade]

I think the reason you may not have had any responses regarding your brain storming for avoiding false signals Phil is that if anyone had a good answer it would "solve" most forex issues

Marylin looks pretty good to me so far (still early in testing of course). It is painful watching some of the big gains reverse but, as you have said, your impressive testing has shown that if we want those big trends then we just have to stick with it.

If I have any brainwaves for improvements I will post them!

Thanks,
Dave.

Thks Dave.

[fluegel]

phil,

I feel really sorry for not being able to contribute to the improvement of Marilyn so far, but this is a daily trader, so I think we need more time even just to confirm how the current Marilyn behaves in various market conditions.

Today I newly set up two different demo accounts, one with Saturday candles as I posted earlier and one with Alpari without Saturday/Sunday candles, to compare and check for difference in performance. Unfortunately all Marilyn trades on my first demo account were accidentally closed by another EA on the same account. I had to start afresh...

At the moment, the only improvement I can think of is, as others have already proposed, to use BE or trailing stop or jumping stop to secure profit while it is there. But, if your backtests have already proven that they reduce profit in the long run, there is nothing I can suggest...

Having losing trades is a part of the game. I'm ready to take them. For me, the current Marilyn looks "too good to be true" even as it is. I'm pretty happy if it behaves just as intended and is able to reproduce the backtest results to the extent possible.

I'm really grateful to you for allowing us to test such a good EA so generously! I hope I would be able to contribute to the development in some way.

fluegel

[phil_trade]

phil,

I feel really sorry for not being able to contribute to the improvement of Marilyn so far, but this is a daily trader, so I think we need more time even just to confirm how the current Marilyn behaves in various market conditions.

Today I newly set up two different demo accounts, one with Saturday candles as I posted earlier and one with Alpari without Saturday/Sunday candles, to compare and check for difference in performance. Unfortunately all Marilyn trades on my first demo account were accidentally closed by another EA on the same account. I had to start afresh...

At the moment, the only improvement I can think of is, as others have already proposed, to use BE or trailing stop or jumping stop to secure profit while it is there. But, if your backtests have already proven that they reduce profit in the long run, there is nothing I can suggest...

Having losing trades is a part of the game. I'm ready to take them. For me, the current Marilyn looks "too good to be true" even as it is. I'm pretty happy if it behaves just as intended and is able to reproduce the backtest results to the extent possible.

I'm really grateful to you for allowing us to test such a good EA so generously! I hope I would be able to contribute to the development in some way.

fluegel

thks and good tests !

[sponn]

BTW is there a big difference when broker has or hasn't got a Sunday candle ?

[phil_trade]

BTW is there a big difference when broker has or hasn't got a Sunday candle ?

Yes ! Stoch / MA and MACD have a special (wrong ?) value on sunday candle.

in my Windev/Empty4 system, I skip this value when looking for example to the last 3 MACD.