The Captains Chest - Naked Trading & Other Stuff

The forum for Captain Jack and CJ related thingies.
Post Reply
User avatar
Pedigree
Trader
Posts: 226
Joined: Thu Apr 11, 2013 12:09 pm
Location: Buckinghamshire, UK

Re: The Captains Chest - Naked Trading & Other Stuff

Post by Pedigree »

banteka wrote:
Pedigree wrote:
banteka wrote: The trick is doing things BEFORE they occur. Those candles are RUN FOR PROFITS. MMs should have been given clues about those movements. That is the mission of the Naked Trading method. Remember that a RUN FOR PROFITS is, at the same time, A POSITION BUILDING. They have money...We don't.
Before you run Banteka, could you please explain a bit further what you mean with this. Could you give a few short notes on "RUN FOR PROFITS" and "POSITION BUILDING".
RUN FOR PROFITS: The MMs need to make money. Thus, they move the price very fast in order to obtain profits, as we see when a release or news are about to happen.

POSITION BUILDING: Process whereby MMs place SELLING or BUYING orders in order to take the money in a RUN FOR PROFITS process.

A long candle in H1 is always a Run For Profits process and a Building Position process.
I hope you will bear with me here please. MMs are buying and selling all the time. At what point exactly do they BOOK A PROFIT. Is it possible to define this point? What on the chart helps you to define this point?
User avatar
Pedigree
Trader
Posts: 226
Joined: Thu Apr 11, 2013 12:09 pm
Location: Buckinghamshire, UK

Re: The Captains Chest - Naked Trading & Other Stuff

Post by Pedigree »

Pedigree wrote:
banteka wrote:
Pedigree wrote:
banteka wrote: The trick is doing things BEFORE they occur. Those candles are RUN FOR PROFITS. MMs should have been given clues about those movements. That is the mission of the Naked Trading method. Remember that a RUN FOR PROFITS is, at the same time, A POSITION BUILDING. They have money...We don't.
Before you run Banteka, could you please explain a bit further what you mean with this. Could you give a few short notes on "RUN FOR PROFITS" and "POSITION BUILDING".
RUN FOR PROFITS: The MMs need to make money. Thus, they move the price very fast in order to obtain profits, as we see when a release or news are about to happen.

POSITION BUILDING: Process whereby MMs place SELLING or BUYING orders in order to take the money in a RUN FOR PROFITS process.

A long candle in H1 is always a Run For Profits process and a Building Position process.
I hope you will bear with me here please. MMs are buying and selling all the time. At what point exactly do they BOOK A PROFIT. Is it possible to define this point? What on the chart helps you to define this point?
On weighing things further, I think they book their profit when they switch the direction of price around - right or wrong?

When you buy, you don't book a profit until you close; this closure is actually a sell to take your profit.
Last edited by Pedigree on Fri Aug 02, 2013 6:51 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
banteka
Trader
Posts: 65
Joined: Fri Jul 19, 2013 10:30 am

Re: The Captains Chest - Naked Trading & Other Stuff

Post by banteka »

Pedigree wrote:
banteka wrote:
Pedigree wrote:
banteka wrote: The trick is doing things BEFORE they occur. Those candles are RUN FOR PROFITS. MMs should have been given clues about those movements. That is the mission of the Naked Trading method. Remember that a RUN FOR PROFITS is, at the same time, A POSITION BUILDING. They have money...We don't.
Before you run Banteka, could you please explain a bit further what you mean with this. Could you give a few short notes on "RUN FOR PROFITS" and "POSITION BUILDING".
RUN FOR PROFITS: The MMs need to make money. Thus, they move the price very fast in order to obtain profits, as we see when a release or news are about to happen.

POSITION BUILDING: Process whereby MMs place SELLING or BUYING orders in order to take the money in a RUN FOR PROFITS process.

A long candle in H1 is always a Run For Profits process and a Building Position process.
I hope you will bear with me here please. MMs are buying and selling all the time. At what point exactly do they BOOK A PROFIT. Is it possible to define this point? What on the chart helps you to define this point?
In a VERY FAST MOVEMENT, a very long candle, MARUBOZU kind, They are very easy to identify in M15.
Follow my trades in MYFXBOOK
Image
User avatar
banteka
Trader
Posts: 65
Joined: Fri Jul 19, 2013 10:30 am

Re: The Captains Chest - Naked Trading & Other Stuff

Post by banteka »

Pedigree wrote:
Pedigree wrote:
banteka wrote:
Pedigree wrote:
banteka wrote: The trick is doing things BEFORE they occur. Those candles are RUN FOR PROFITS. MMs should have been given clues about those movements. That is the mission of the Naked Trading method. Remember that a RUN FOR PROFITS is, at the same time, A POSITION BUILDING. They have money...We don't.
Before you run Banteka, could you please explain a bit further what you mean with this. Could you give a few short notes on "RUN FOR PROFITS" and "POSITION BUILDING".
RUN FOR PROFITS: The MMs need to make money. Thus, they move the price very fast in order to obtain profits, as we see when a release or news are about to happen.

POSITION BUILDING: Process whereby MMs place SELLING or BUYING orders in order to take the money in a RUN FOR PROFITS process.

A long candle in H1 is always a Run For Profits process and a Building Position process.
I hope you will bear with me here please. MMs are buying and selling all the time. At what point exactly do they BOOK A PROFIT. Is it possible to define this point? What on the chart helps you to define this point?
On weighing things further, I think they book their profit when they switch the direction of price around - right or wrong?
If that switch has volume and in M15 appears a very long candle, then YES. Speed, Height and VOLUME are the keys. However, sometimes they use several candles. Remember the Stop Hunt?
Follow my trades in MYFXBOOK
Image
User avatar
Pedigree
Trader
Posts: 226
Joined: Thu Apr 11, 2013 12:09 pm
Location: Buckinghamshire, UK

Re: The Captains Chest - Naked Trading & Other Stuff

Post by Pedigree »

banteka wrote:
Pedigree wrote:
banteka wrote:
Pedigree wrote:
banteka wrote: The trick is doing things BEFORE they occur. Those candles are RUN FOR PROFITS. MMs should have been given clues about those movements. That is the mission of the Naked Trading method. Remember that a RUN FOR PROFITS is, at the same time, A POSITION BUILDING. They have money...We don't.
Before you run Banteka, could you please explain a bit further what you mean with this. Could you give a few short notes on "RUN FOR PROFITS" and "POSITION BUILDING".
RUN FOR PROFITS: The MMs need to make money. Thus, they move the price very fast in order to obtain profits, as we see when a release or news are about to happen.

POSITION BUILDING: Process whereby MMs place SELLING or BUYING orders in order to take the money in a RUN FOR PROFITS process.

A long candle in H1 is always a Run For Profits process and a Building Position process.
I hope you will bear with me here please. MMs are buying and selling all the time. At what point exactly do they BOOK A PROFIT. Is it possible to define this point? What on the chart helps you to define this point?
In a VERY FAST MOVEMENT, a very long candle, MARUBOZU kind, They are very easy to identify in M15.
I don't really understand that - what they do to cause the long candle and how exactly that puts money in their pockets. I will go weigh it up and maybe come back with a better question - if you haven't run out of patience with me by then! You've been soooo good. Thank you.
User avatar
banteka
Trader
Posts: 65
Joined: Fri Jul 19, 2013 10:30 am

Re: The Captains Chest - Naked Trading & Other Stuff

Post by banteka »

Pedigree wrote:
When you buy, you don't book a profit until you close;
I don't agree. You are in profits WHILE YOU HAVE YOUR ORDER OPENED, that's is how MMs consider it.
They do not mind whether you are wining or loosing. Their mission is to force you to close your position by triggering your Stop Loss or simply by psychology. And thats the way you have to look at MMs. Yesterday I opened a LONG position in EUR/USD just BEFORE an important release. The movement started violently against my direction and in a moment I was at -350 euros. But I knew that it was only a deception of the FOX. Signals were clearly that MMs were BULLS. A quarter of hour later, price rose beyond my entry point, giving me a wining trade. Those signals were previously provided by PRICE + VOLUME analysis.
Last edited by banteka on Fri Aug 02, 2013 7:04 am, edited 1 time in total.
Follow my trades in MYFXBOOK
Image
User avatar
Pedigree
Trader
Posts: 226
Joined: Thu Apr 11, 2013 12:09 pm
Location: Buckinghamshire, UK

Re: The Captains Chest - Naked Trading & Other Stuff

Post by Pedigree »

banteka wrote:
Pedigree wrote:
When you buy, you don't book a profit until you close;
I don't agree. You are in profits WHILE YOU HAVE YOUR ORDER OPENED, that's is how MMs consider it.
They do not mind whether you are wining or loosing. Their mission is to force you to close your position by triggering your Stop Loss or simply by psychology. And thats the way you have to look at MMs. Yesterday I opened a LONG position in EUR/USD just BEFORE an important release. The movement started violently against my direction and in a moment I was at -350 euros. But I knew that it was only a deception of the FOX. Signals were clearly that MMs were BULLS. A quarter of hour later, price rose beyond my entry point, giving me a wining trade. Those signals were previously provided by PRICE + VOLUME analysis.
Thank you for so indulging me here Banteka, but is it not true that the only reason they could not take your money is that you did NOT close in loss? They could not book you as profit because you did NOT close. I am surely missing a point here.
User avatar
banteka
Trader
Posts: 65
Joined: Fri Jul 19, 2013 10:30 am

Re: The Captains Chest - Naked Trading & Other Stuff

Post by banteka »

Pedigree wrote: I don't really understand that - what they do to cause the long candle and how exactly that puts money in their pockets. I will go weigh it up and maybe come back with a better question - if you haven't run out of patience with me by then! You've been soooo good. Thank you.
Well. First of all you have to think that there are always retailer's pending orders up and down of the price.
Second you have to believe that MMs KNOW EXACTLY where those pending orders are and how much of them in each direction. This is a fact. You are being spied by the MMs. ALWAYS.
Third: the MMs, at a given moment, have more LONGS than SHORTS in their portfolio. So they have to SELL because the imbalance is to the LONGS side. Understand?. Now, in order for them to SELL, someone has to BUY. Ok?
So the perfect movement is PUSHING UP THE PRICE giving the fake sensation that price is going to rise. Hence, you, as a retailer, BUY. From WHO? From the MMs. So they rise the price making two very important things:
1.- Hit the LONG PENDING ORDERS. Those orders are BUY ORDERS in fact.
2.- Induce other traders to BUY in that moment. More SELLING for the MMs.

Well. Then, when you as BUYER and PENDING ORDERS ARE TRAPPED, they switch the directiion till two things occur:

1.- STOP LOSES are triggered, making the previous LONGS orders become SELLING ones.
2.- Using psycology to force other traders to exit with loses, more SELLING ORDERS to the process.

And the price violently DROPS...like a nuclear chain reaction. MMs only need to find the critical mass.

The money is obtained because THEY SELL. And then, the imbalance is in their SELL side. And so on.

Please, give me a rest... :)
Follow my trades in MYFXBOOK
Image
User avatar
Pedigree
Trader
Posts: 226
Joined: Thu Apr 11, 2013 12:09 pm
Location: Buckinghamshire, UK

Re: The Captains Chest - Naked Trading & Other Stuff

Post by Pedigree »

banteka wrote:
Pedigree wrote: I don't really understand that - what they do to cause the long candle and how exactly that puts money in their pockets. I will go weigh it up and maybe come back with a better question - if you haven't run out of patience with me by then! You've been soooo good. Thank you.
Well. First of all you have to think that there are always retailer's pending orders up and down of the price.
Second you have to believe that MMs KNOW EXACTLY where those pending orders are and how much of them in each direction. This is a fact. You are being spied by the MMs. ALWAYS.
Third: the MMs, at a given moment, have more LONGS than SHORTS in their portfolio. So they have to SELL because the imbalance is to the LONGS side. Understand?. Now, in order for them to SELL, someone has to BUY. Ok?
So the perfect movement is PUSHING UP THE PRICE giving the fake sensation that price is going to rise. Hence, you, as a retailer, BUY. From WHO? From the MMs. So they rise the price making two very important things:
1.- Hit the LONG PENDING ORDERS. Those orders are BUY ORDERS in fact.
2.- Induce other traders to BUY in that moment. More SELLING for the MMs.

Well. Then, when you as BUYER and PENDING ORDERS ARE TRAPPED, they switch the directiion till two things occur:

1.- STOP LOSES are triggered, making the previous LONGS orders become SELLING ones.
2.- Using psycology to force other traders to exit with loses, more SELLING ORDERS to the process.

And the price violently DROPS...like a nuclear chain reaction. MMs only need to find the critical mass.

The money is obtained because THEY SELL. And then, the imbalance is in their SELL side. And so on.

Please, give me a rest... :)
Your rest is very well deserved Banteka! You have given so much here, and I have certainly not fully taken it all in. I will go back and dwell further on the last couple pages. Thank you very much for your time and I wish you a lot of fox meat to roast by the end of the day. :D
User avatar
pips400
Trader
Posts: 279
Joined: Tue Jan 01, 2013 9:03 pm

Re: The Captains Chest - Naked Trading & Other Stuff

Post by pips400 »

This isn't for Banteka as he's entitled to his well earned rest, but I do have some concerns about the difficulty of reading volume, and like all other aspects of naked trading it's about context and how all the bits fit together as a whole, and not just taking one element and trading off of it, but you have to put all the pieces together otherwise you're gonna get slaughtered IMHO

I could have taken any price chart but the AUDUSD is a good example. I've marked the bearish candles with high volume on the H1 chart for the past week, and there was no reversal but only a continued down trend. If the volume is high and the candle is bearish then it means bears have won (albeit those bears may be made from both retailers and MM's), and if the volume is high and the candle bullish then the bulls have won etc. Once there is momentum signifying the MM have got price moving in their direction, they want increase volume in their direction because that means more profit, it's just at some point if the MM have a lot of positions open they need to close them, and that's going to create volume also.

So for me personally, I'm still learning all this along with everyone else, volume analysis takes on a particular significance when combined with timing. When I say timing I mean help to identify the stop hunt, and also after the 3 or so levels when fox is looking for exit and reverse. If you take volume on its own, and I could be wrong so forgive me, I think it's a recipe for disaster, because you have to understand the overall context and where you are in the market cycle.

It's NFP today, so I'm not sure whether to stay out or have some fun

Happy trading

Pips400
audusdih1.jpg
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Post Reply

Return to “Captain Jack's forum”