nanningbob » Tue Apr 29, 2014 10:42 pm wrote:
10.9 is is strictly day charts and higher. You take 1 or 2 trades a month and you can sit on a trade for weeks or months at a time. You enter and sit on the trade. I liken it to setting the stove to 99 C and waiting for water to boil. You either have the patience to trade that way or not. It is the simplest of the systems but takes the most patience. Because of Easter and the Ukraine thing you might as well as gone on vacation for April. Below is the eur/usd chart. For the last 3 weeks it has stayed in a 100 pip range. Well that is a lot of fun. Except for some of the commodity currency drops the last two weeks there has been nothing much to trade. I may get a 3% increase of my account for the month. Hey that's the market right now. Part of trading is recognizing the fundamentals and that they just arent there right now. I mean you can analyze this thing to death but you arent going to be making money if the markets are just marching in place. Except for a couple of commodity currencies like eur/nzd and gbp/nzd everything has stayed within that 100-150 pip range.
If you want to learn demark TL put demark TL in google and go read. Ton of material out there. Those are not fractals on your screen those are where the lines for TL in the past which I did explain in my first couple of pages in the thread. I showed how to use them to determine TL in the past.
I dont agonize about my entrances. If I get a trade signal. I look at my CSS read and either enter or dont enter. If I enter I take what I think is my best entry point and I go with the trade. That can be a MA line, TL, or xxx.000 or xxx.050 line. Then I let the trade develop.
The most important tool I use in trading is the CSS and it has the fewest views. Everything I do is based on my daily reads of the CSS. If I had a choice of one tool to trade with that would be it. If the GBP is higher than the JPY I dont try buying the JPY unless I want to counter trade.
I only trade Forex and nothing else. It is a ranging market and if you do it right (lot size to account size) Your losses are minimal. I dont have to worry about a company going broke and price going to zero. (sorry gold crowd but gold is about ready to drop again)
Apologies Bob,
I thought I had read the entire thread, but I clearly missed the trendlines posts on page 3-4. I was familiar with a few systems based on trendlines, drawn from fractals (the yellow circles are also fractals at least according to how Empty4 defines them!

) or swing highs lows, but never found them consistently profitable due to false breaks, whipsaws etc.
I agree on the CSS, it is the most interesting thing I have seen in a while, and gives great confidence in holding trades - the hardest thing to do in daily strategies.
I understand the forex argument as regards ranging, but I do not expect SPX,US30 or GER30 indices or commodities to go to zero, and as I mentioned, I've been using 10.9 (likely incorrectly) to trade indices and commodities on a demo for a few weeks now and the results are encouraging. At least they've been moving! Of course another big reason to beware, is that you do not have the CSS to give clues to direction.
Back to 10.9 - unfortunately I still have some questions:
Entrances
1) Do you use only stop orders in the direction of your trade or do you also place pending limit orders at MA lines, TL, or xxx.000 or xxx.050 lines looking for better entries if price continues in wrong direction for a while?
2) Is CSS the only filter you use, or do you also use the monthly 2MA and weekly 2MA as trend indicators?
3) Considering that your chosen MA line, TL, or xxx.000 or xxx.050 line on the daily chart may be quite a distance away when the sto7 signal is given, it is likely (especially in recent tightly ranging markets) that the sto7 will also have travelled quite a way to its opposite side by the time the pending order is hit, so do you have any rules for when you would remove the pending orders?
4) Conversely do you try to anticipate where the w2.1 and sto 7 will be (by looking at weekly open and last 7 closes) when a MA line, TL, or xxx.000 or xxx.050 line is crossed and place pending orders anticipating the correct signals?
Exits
These quotes are from different posts on page 1&2:
"Get a signal, enter and stay until the signal changes. If you get it right you will add to your positions like professional big time traders do. "
"EXITS
1. STO7 hits the top OR
2. W2.1 goes back to the bottom"
a) I have been exiting when sto7 hits 100 or 0 or the w2.1 changes, so it is very rare for a trade to last even a week and does not allow a building of positions. I think that to hold trades, you must be using a combination of CSS + your uptrend/downtrend MAs, and ignoring Mon-Tues, and possibly using the monthly 2.1 to hold these trades even when sto7 & w2.1 signal to exit? or are you in the market 100% of the time and keep adding buy positions until you get an actual sell signal?
Thanks Bob for everything!