Clearly Jess had take to heart my promise about the harsh words and had learned that she is indeed allowed to show some personality.
The following week, she bounced into The Shame of The Black Hole of Calcutta and asked, "How did the universe begin?" Starting with me and alternating, here is how the exchange continued - bear in mind that this child is 12.
"Erm. Have you heard of The Big Bang theory."
"Of course I have. But how could it have happened?"
"Erm. Sorry?"
"Well, before the Big Bang was supposed to be nothing, ok?"
"Yeeeessssss........"
"So how could the Big Bang have happened when there was nothing for it to happen with?"
"To be honest Jess, that has always bothered me. I cannot imagine nothing."
"No. Me neither. How can there be nothing? There has to be
something because nothing would just be nothing, and nothing can arise from nothing."
"Sad to say this Jess, but you and I think alike." Part of me was dreading the inevitable next bit, another part of me was enjoying watching this 12 year old mind at work. I
love watching clever children think through a problem.
"I thought about the religious route. So some people believe that God created the world?"
Yep. The conversation had indeed gone where I expected it would. "They do, and I know what you are about to ask."
"So who, or what, created God?"
"To be honest darling, I never bothered going that far. I am an atheist."
"Which leaves this problem. God cannot exist because there was nothing before God, and so God cannot have been created and so cannot exist Nothing can be created from nothing, and nothing existed before the Big Bang, so neither God nor the Big Bang can have created the universe."
"Yes."
"Therefore, we do not exist. I have been going around all day telling people that we do not exist. I have occasionally felt the need to run away from people I have told do not exist, but I am very small and very fast and so have not been beaten up yet."
Chris, my wife, long ago posited this theory: we do not actually exist in the physical form that we think we occupy. We are in fact brains in bottles being experimented on by alien beings. Old Nutter and Young Nutter would rub along quite well, it seems to me.
So I offered this theory to Jess. She thought about it for a while then pronounced, "Naaah. Impossible. We do not exist."
"Just play me the piano, child."
My life is complicated sometimes.
